Abigail L. —
"I just had breakfast there- deluxe bagel since I wanted an egg sandwich. Cheddar cheese with flavor , thank you, sausage with real seasoning and the bagel was a good chewy texture without being puffed up or dense. I am an espresso drinker and that was delish and served in an appropriate small cup. Go there! This place is a keeper!"
Kacey D. —
"Our family ordered the Bronx, Queens, and a French Toast bagel....all of which was a big hit with the adults and the 3 year old. The cookies and cream latte is money! And we got cookie sandwiches to eat later because we filled up on the bagel sandwiches. Great music if you want to kick back for a bit or if your kid likes to dance."
Carmen M. —
"The honey walnut spread is to die for! Had a blue berry bagel with the spread! I honestly don't think you could go wrong with anything on the menu! The people are awesome and super friendly! Welcome to the neighborhood!"
Donald G. —
"Great Job! Restaurant is neat and clean!
Bialy Bronx was my pick and it was over the top with sirachra bacon cream cheese and roast beef. Congrats Toney and Sarah!"
Emily I. —
"Great food/drinks and atmosphere! So many choices and even options for those who eat gluten free or dairy free"
Shayla H. —
"Great variety of delicious house made cream cheeses! Fresh sliced meats, fantastic house blend coffee, and a very relaxed atmosphere. I highly recommend!"
Anthony C. —
"Extremely friendly and helpful.. bagels are fantastic. Can't wait to make this our new place for breakfast!!"
Amanda M. —
"I got the queens bagel and iced chai tea with vanilla syrup - very, very good! Will definitely be back"
Jackie P. —
"Stopped in on a recommendation from a friend and will definitely be back! We had The Manhattan and The Queens. Fresh ingedients make all the difference."
Rebecca M. —
"The Brooklyn is amazing! Prices are great! The owners are great people"
Lindsey F. —
"Such good food and coffee!! So many fun unique options!"
Robert A. —
"Perfect breakfast stop! The food, staff, and atmosphere exceeded all of my expectations. Thank you!!"
Kent R. —
"So, I wondered what kinda New York guy I'd be...ends up I'm a Manhattan! As is often the case it might be the Sriracha! Great food and hospitality! I'm guessing one might not always score smiles and free water in the Big Apple, though! :-) Keep up the great work Tony & Sarah!"
Garret Y. —
"As New Jersey natives, we have high standards for bagels. 5 Borough Bagels did not disappoint. The bagels were nicely dense and chewy, and the bialys were excellent. (We've never met anyone outside of New York / New Jersey who had ever heard of a bialy.) They offer a nice variety of cream cheeses and sandwich fillings, and the espresso machine is an added bonus. We have yet to try their fresh-squeezed orange juice, but we will definitely be back soon."
Stephanie P. —
"Love this place!!! Their bagels are to die for. Perfectly cooked, slightly crispy on outside and very soft on the inside. Their house blended cream cheeses are amazing. I was able to taste test some before picking. I ultimately got the Manhattan. The sand which was much bigger than expected with fresh veggies, meat and bacon. I got it with siracha bacon cream cheese, and wow!! The best bagel sandwich I honestly have had. I also ordered the iced oost which is my new favorite coffee drink. I couldn't believe how good it was!! So many decisions and good choices to choose from. They have a flavor for any taste bud. You will not be disappointed!!"
Carmen M. —
"This place is awesome! Their bagels are soft & the honey walnut spread is to die for! I defiantly will be visiting this place a lot! Welcome to the neighborhood!"
Anna B. —
"I have been excited for this particular bagel shop to open up since the day I heard of it. I made sure to try some things off the menu on their grand opening, and it did not disappoint! I have already been their more than once because it's the perfect breakfast/lunch spot for when I'm in a hurry. All of their bagels are served soft, and the homemade cream cheese is out of this world! (Not an over exaggeration, trust me). But my absolute favorite thing on the menu so far is the freshly squeezed orange juice. I highly recommend giving this one-of-a-kind bagel shop a try, and support our local businesses!"
"Best bagel since I've moved back to Iowa. I had the French toast bagel and loved it. They are going into the regular breakfast rotation."